Guide for parents

My 5-year-old is ahead in math. What comes next?

Your child counts past 20, adds small numbers in their head and asks for harder ones. Here is how to tell what kind of ahead that is, what usually comes next, and three things to try tonight that go deeper, not only faster.

What “ahead” can mean

Being ahead in math at 5 or 6 usually shows up in one of two ways, and most children have some of each. One is fluency: counting far, knowing small sums quickly, answering before you finish the question. The other is understanding: being able to say why an answer is right, solve the same idea in a new form, and notice patterns nobody pointed out.

A quick way to tell them apart is to ask one more question after a right answer. Say your child knows that 6 and 3 make 9. Ask, “How did you know?” and then, “Can you make 9 a different way?” A child who answers “because 6, then 7, 8, 9” and then offers 5 and 4 understands what adding is doing. A child who just says “I know it” may have the fact memorized, which is useful too, but there is room to dig.

Neither kind is better. Fast recall saves effort later, and understanding is what lets a child use a fact in a problem they have never seen. For a child who is ahead, the most useful next step is often to build understanding around what they already do quickly, before racing to bigger numbers.

What it often looks like at 5, 6 and 7

Children vary a lot here, and a child can be ahead in one area and right on track in another. This is a loose picture of a child who is ahead, not a timetable.

  • Around 5. Counts well past 20, sometimes to 100, and can start counting from any number. Adds and takes away small amounts, sometimes on fingers and sometimes in their head. May read two-digit numbers on buses and doors and ask what comes after a hundred.
  • Around 6. Adds and subtracts within 20 with little effort and starts asking about bigger numbers. Begins to see that 34 is three tens and four ones, and may count by fives or tens without being shown. Often loves “What if?” questions: what is a million plus one?
  • Around 7. Works with two-digit numbers, sometimes in their own invented ways. Starts to notice that three groups of four is the same as four groups of three, and that two pieces only count as halves when they are the same size. Can explain a strategy, though often in words that make sense only to them, which is fine.

What usually comes after adding within 20

In many US schools, once adding and taking away within 20 feels easy, the next steps run roughly like this. None of it has to be rushed, and every one of them can be explored in play at home.

  • Place value. Seeing that the 3 in 34 means three tens. This is one of the big ideas of the first school years, and it is what makes adding two-digit numbers make sense.
  • Two-digit numbers. Comparing them, adding and taking away with them, and later regrouping (what happens when the ones add up to ten or more).
  • Early multiplication ideas. Skip-counting by 2s, 5s and 10s, and seeing equal groups: three bags with four apples in each. Formal times tables usually come later.
  • Fractions as equal shares. Halves and quarters of a shape or a snack, where the key word is equal.
  • Money, time and measuring. Counting coins, telling the time to the hour and half hour, comparing lengths.

Going deeper means spending time on these ideas from new angles rather than only drilling bigger sums. Some easy ways in:

  • Growing patterns. Build a staircase from blocks, one, then two, then three. How many blocks would the whole staircase need with ten steps? How do you know without building it? (It is 55: 1 + 2 + … + 10.)
  • Estimation. Guess how many spoons are in the drawer, or grapes in the bowl, then check by counting in groups. Was the guess close? What would you guess next time?
  • Time. “Dinner is at six. It is five o’clock now. How long?” Let them watch the clock hand and check.
  • Puzzles with more than one answer. “I am thinking of two numbers that add to 12. What could they be? How many pairs can you find?”
  • “Convince me.” When your child gets an answer, ask them to prove it to you, with objects, a drawing or words. Explaining is a skill of its own, and ahead children often skip it.

Three things to try tonight

Each takes about ten minutes and uses things you already have at home. Pick one; you do not need all three.

1. Plates and pasta (equal groups)

You need four small plates or bowls and a handful of dry pasta, beans or small blocks. If a younger brother or sister is around, keep the pasta, beans and coins out of their reach.

  1. Set out three plates. Ask your child to put two pieces of pasta on each plate.
  2. Ask, “How many altogether?” Then ask, “How did you count?” One at a time, or two, four, six?
  3. Add a fourth plate with two more. How many now? Did they count everything again, or just add on?
  4. Now turn it around. Give them twelve pieces and three plates: “Share these fairly so every plate has the same.” Then try twelve on four plates, and twelve on two.
  5. Finish with a puzzle: thirteen pieces on three plates. What happens to the one left over? There is no wrong answer here; let them decide what is fair.

This is the idea underneath multiplication and division, with no symbols at all: so many groups of the same size, and sharing one amount into equal groups.

2. Fold and share (halves and quarters)

You need three sheets of scrap paper, all the same size, and a pair of child-safe scissors.

  1. Call the first sheet a pizza. Ask your child to fold it so the two sides match exactly, open it, then cut along the fold. Do both people get the same amount? Keep these two halves.
  2. Cut the second sheet into two pieces that are clearly not the same size. Ask, “Is this halves?” Listen to the reason. (It is two pieces, but not halves, because halves are equal.)
  3. Fold a third sheet in half, then in half again. How many parts now? Are they equal? What would you call one of them?
  4. Cut the third sheet along its folds into quarters. Put one quarter next to one of the halves from the first sheet. Which is bigger? Many children expect the quarter to be bigger “because 4 is more than 2,” so this is a lovely surprise to discover with their own hands.

3. The kitchen shop (counting coins)

You need about ten pennies, four nickels and two dimes, sticky notes, a pen and five small things to “sell,” like a toy car, an apple and a book.

  1. Sort the coins together and name each one: a penny is 1 cent, a nickel is 5 cents, a dime is 10 cents.
  2. Write a price on a sticky note for each thing: 3¢, 7¢, 12¢, 15¢, 20¢. Stick them on.
  3. You are the customer first. Your child is the shopkeeper and checks that you paid the right amount.
  4. Swap. Your child buys something and counts out the coins, starting with the biggest value.
  5. The stretch: “Can you pay for the 15¢ car a different way?” A dime and a nickel, three nickels, a dime and five pennies. How many ways can they find?

Counting a dime and two nickels means counting by tens and then by fives, so this game is skip-counting in disguise.

A printable to keep going: skip-counting trails

Our free skip-counting trails sheet has six number trails with some stepping stones left blank. The first trails count by 2s, 5s and 10s from the start. The next one starts somewhere unexpected, one hides its rule, and the last one is blank for your child to make up their own. The stones are big enough for a young child to write a number in.

Read a trail out loud together, then let your child fill in the blank stones. Before they write, ask what they think the next number will be and why. Do one or two trails at a sitting, and keep the mystery trail for when the others feel easy. All you need is the printed page and a pencil or crayon. It prints on one page, US Letter or A4, with no sign-up.

Common mix-ups, and what to do

  • Counting far, but writing big numbers the way they sound. A child who counts past 100 may write 1005 for one hundred five, or 10010 for one hundred ten. Write the number together and point: “Where are the hundreds? The tens? The ones?” The words and the digits line up slowly.
  • “A quarter is bigger, because 4 is bigger than 2.” Very common. Fold paper and compare the pieces side by side, rather than explaining the rule.
  • Any two pieces are halves. Children often call any split “halves,” even when one piece is huge. Keep asking, “Is it fair? Would you swap?”
  • Bigger coin, more money. A nickel is bigger than a dime but worth less. Sort coins by value, not size, and say the value every time you count one.
  • The equals sign means “the answer comes next.” Many children think 9 = 4 + 5 is written wrong. Read it as “is the same as,” and try puzzles like 3 + 4 = __ + 5.
  • Speed over sense. Quick children sometimes guess and move on. Praise checking as much as being right: “You stopped and checked. That is what mathematicians do.”

Keeping it fun, and talking with the teacher

Children who are ahead can tire of repetition quickly, and some get upset at a mistake because mistakes are rare for them. Keep games short, follow their questions, and make it normal to be stuck for a moment. Puzzles with several answers help a lot here, because there is no single answer to be fast at.

If your child seems bored at school or comes home with work that feels too easy, talk with their teacher. Share what you see at home, such as the kind of questions they ask and the problems they enjoy, and ask what the class is working on and how you can support it. Teachers often have ways to stretch a child within the class. Follow the school’s lead on what comes next, and use home time for play, puzzles and talk rather than racing ahead in a workbook.

Where this comes from

This guide draws on Teaching Math to Young Children, a practice guide by Douglas Frye and colleagues, published by the What Works Clearinghouse at the U.S. Department of Education’s Institute of Education Sciences in 2013 (NCEE 2014-4005). It was written for preschool and kindergarten teachers.

In our words: the guide recommends teaching number along a developmental progression, a kind of road map of which skills build on which, so the next step is chosen from what a child can already do and, when a child struggles, an earlier step can be practiced. It suggests moving on to slightly harder problems as children become more able, finding out what each child already knows and building new ideas on it, and asking open-ended questions that get children to use what they know. It also suggests pretend stores as a way to practice counting money. The list of what comes after adding within 20 is our own summary of a typical US school sequence, not the guide’s.

How PencilWise practices it

The PencilWise math path continues past adding within 20 to skills such as Tens and ones, Skip-counting, Equal groups and Halves, quarters and other simple fractions. A few quick questions find where to start, and every word is read aloud. Practice moves on only when your child succeeds without help, and skills come back later for review.

PencilWise is built for ages 5–7, and its math path ends around adding two-digit numbers with regrouping, multiplying small numbers, simple fractions, coins and telling the time. It suits a child who is ahead and still has those steps to explore. A child already comfortable with all of them will find little new here, and puzzles, games and the ideas above will serve them better.

Related

PencilWise is a short daily session of reading, writing and math for ages 5–7. Every word is read aloud. Practice moves on only when your child succeeds without help.